The Gratitude Gap: Why Men Feel Numb and How to Get Your Heart Back

In this Thanksgiving-week episode, Brent dives deep into one of the most common — and least talked about — struggles men face: feeling emotionally numb even when life is objectively good. Drawing from neuroscience, scripture, Stoic philosophy, and practical daily rhythms, he shows men how to turn gratitude from a concept into a neurological trigger that reopens the heart.

If you’ve ever found yourself wanting to feel grateful but unable to access the emotion… this episode will change your week.

What You’ll Learn:

• Why chronic stress shuts down the brain’s gratitude circuits
• How scripture validates emotional exhaustion (not shames it)
• The Stoic discipline that rewires your perspective
• How to practice gratitude even when you don’t feel it
• A 3-minute neuroscience-based gratitude activation
• How to reconnect with your wife and kids through spoken gratitude
• How to show up to Thanksgiving present, not numb

Join the Email List:

Get weekly tools and frameworks at PurposeDrivenMen.com

Sponsors:

MyPillow

Free MyPillow Promo Code "THRIVE" for up to 80% off your entire order at MyPillow!   

Get up to 80% off EVERYTHING at MyPillow with promo code "THRIVE"! We are proudly sponsored by MyPillow offers quality products at affordable prices. Use the code for savings on sheets, pillows, slippers, and more. Shop 250+ American-made items and support both the podcast and a great company. Enjoy the comfort and savings today! 🥳         www.mypillow.com/thrive

Want to Share Your Message with the World?
Looking to be a guest on a podcast and reach a wider audience? Or maybe you host your own podcast and want to find amazing, high-quality guests—without the hassle?

If you answered yes, PodMatch is exactly what you need. Join Here: https://www.joinpodmatch.com/driven2thrive

Support our podcast: 

Support us on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/thefallibleman 

Buy us a Coffee! https://www.buymeacoffee.com/thefallibleman

S06E43 of the Driven 2 Thrive Broadcast

Want to be a guest on Driven 2 Thrive: Purpose, Growth, and Lasting Impact For Men? Send David Dowlen a message on PodMatch, here: https://www.podmatch.com/hostdetailpreview/driven2thrive

DISCLAIMER: This post & video is designed for educational and/or informational purposes only and should not be used in any other manner. Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with the links that I provide I may receive a small commission. There is no additional charge to you, and I appreciate your support!

Transcript

The Gratitude Gap: Why Men Feel Numb and How to Get Your Heart Back

Brent Dowlen: [00:00:00] Have you ever hit a moment in your life where you look around at everything and you have, and just like your wife, your kids, your home, your job, and you know you're supposed to feel grateful, but you don't feel much of anything at all. You're not mad, you're not depressed, you're not falling apart, you're just numb.

Well. If that's you, stick with me. Because what you're feeling isn't failure. It's not a moral flaw. It's not even in gratitude. It's something entirely different. And today, today we're gonna fix it. By the end of this episode, you're gonna understand why you feel emotionally disconnected. Even when you have a life you're thankful for, you're gonna learn the science behind it, the scripture that speaks to it in a simple process.

It can help you reconnect with your own heart. Before Thanksgiving hits this week, [00:01:00] you're gonna walk into your home this week 

present, not empty. Let's get into it. Now. I wanna start with the truth that most men never hear. You are not ungrateful. Your brain is overloaded. 

Chronic stress. Raises cortisol and cortisol, literally dulls your dopamine receptors.

Couple that with, you know, the dopamine overstimulation that actually destroys those as well. And when that happens, that part of your brain that normally lights up when you think of blessings, things you're grateful for, that goes quiet because you've just dulled that out. Your nervous system goes into protection mode instead of connection mode.

In other words, your brain is just too busy surviving to 

let you feel thankful. [00:02:00] Scriptural

and scripture actually names this proverbs tells us hope deferred makes the heart sick. You ever feel that? Not broken, not hopeless, just. Tired. Well, Marcus Aurelius said The soul becomes dyed with the color of his thoughts. When your thoughts are all carrying survival mode, 

when everything is just, 

I just gotta endure.

Well, 

it dies. Everything gray. Here's the point, 

guys. Gratitude isn't gone. It is just kind of buried. You're not ungrateful. Your brain has just been in survival mode far too long to feel anything else. And one of the most important things to get you out of survi [00:03:00] survival mode is actually to get enough rest because everything is more difficult and less effective when you're tired.

And if you're trying to get better sleep, reset your nervous system and actually feel. Rested walking into the holidays, and you already know I'm gonna point you towards our friends over at MyPillow right now. Our friends, MyPillow, Mike Lindell, have the holiday specials just rolling out guys. And if you follow me on social media, no doubt you'll see you're seeing the Black Friday notifications, my slippers, my towels, pillows, blankets.

Everything in my pillow is on massive discount for the Black Friday sales that are already going on. So go to mypillow.com, use promo code Thrive. Call 1-800-794-FIVE 8 3 4. You'll get the very best deals they've got, and you support this show in the process and help us stay on the air. We're gonna roll into our intro and then right back into this very important conversation today.

The Driven 2 Thrive broadcast purpose, growth, and lasting impact for [00:04:00] men, helping men go from living to thriving. Purpose-filled intentional lives. Welcome to the Driven Thrive broadcast where men learn to lead themselves, their families, and their world with purpose, growth, and lasting impact. I'm your host, Brent Dowlen.

Let's get right back into it. We already discussed one issue that is ex interfering with you, experiencing gratitude and feeling numb. The other culprit stealing from you is just as nasty, and that I'm talking about is bandwidth. You see, your brain has limited emotional battery every day. Work stress drains it.

Money, stress definitely drains it. Mary's tension drains it, parenting drains it. Your own internal dialogue drains it in the world of people with physical disabilities or, uh, other stresses that you can't [00:05:00] see. It's called spoons. You have so many spoons to the day you start your day with say, 50 spoons and everything you do takes something.

Well, guys, that's mostly often referred to for, like I said, with people in communities where you have like permanent injuries or disabilities that are not readily vis visible is used in the autism community. But the truth is, it's just an easy example to explain what I'm talking about. Everything you do throughout your day.

Takes bandwidth. That's why on the channel, we've talked about putting your most important task earlier in the day when you have more bandwidth for it, right? We've talked about managing your energy as opposed to your time, because honestly, it's like holding a gallon jug and poking a hole in the bottom of it.

Once it's out, it's out. It doesn't matter. That's how everybody is. Everybody has a limit for the day. [00:06:00] Your own internal dialogue even drains this limit for you, and often times, by the time we get home, well the battery's just dead. 

You are just fried. You're not feeling

a hundred percent, you're not even feeling 10%. A lot of times. Let's face 

it, the world takes a lot out of you, so you're not not feeling gratitude because you're empty. You are not feeling gratitude because you have no remaining capacity to feel much of anything. Science calls this emotional blunting juices called it weary and heavy burden.

He didn't shame it. He invited it. It picked us. Said It's not events that disturb men, but they're interpretation of events. Your brain is trying to interpret too many things at once and the result well, that's numbness. So before you judge [00:07:00] yourself this week, run a bandwidth check-in mind load, what's consuming your thoughts?

What is consuming your mental spoons, your mental energy physically, what stress is sitting in your body today, unless you've spent much time with a chiropractor and a good one at that, you probably haven't un heard the concept that actually. A lot of people physically carry their stress in their muscles.

That's actually a physical fact. Women carry it slightly different areas than men do. 'cause hey, we're all different, right? But you actually carry a physical manifestation of that stress in your body. Besides the physical stress and load you put on your system every day, what about your soul load? 

What hope has been deferred?

What

heart matter has been 

put off or [00:08:00] crushed. These are all things that are crushing your bandwidth every day, and it's really easy if you aren't really, really good at managing your energy to just be done by the time you get home. Our day takes so much out of us a lot of times that we don't have anything left towards the end of the day.

You're not empty, you're overloaded and overloaded. Hearts can't fill full, which is a requirement for gratitude. There are a lot of men, and I've definitely been one of them many times myself, and it's myself. That's good English. I've definitely been one many times myself and still struggle with this, who have been lodged in survival mode and overloaded with far too much for far too long because we've been sold the pack of lies.

Does this sound familiar? Busy equals success? You may not have actually heard that said, but it's [00:09:00] implied in everything you look at. Busy people are successful people or that money is everything. Well, money has its place and it can help you with a lot of things, but it's not everything. Maybe you've heard a lot if you just work hard enough, long enough.

You'll be success, successful no matter what. It's just putting in enough time and effort. Guys, I know a lot of hard workers who are just burning themselves out. You have to ground yourself in reality, not the lies that were sold frequently by social media and by advertising. You've ground yourself into the dirt for so long.

Trying so hard, doing so much, carrying such a load that the only way to sustain is to become numb, and that's where you're at. Like I said, been there, done that. A lot of us struggle with this. So step number one is to recognize all the [00:10:00] lies. Money is great. It's not everything busy, does not equal success.

Working super hard and grinding away. Won't guarantee success. There's a lot of lies that you're fed every day that you have to stop and question. So first, start recognizing all those lies that are actually stealing your gratitude because they're grinding you into the ground. Step two, though, gratitude can be trained like any other muscle.

So here's the playbook. Put the thanks back in your life as we head towards Thanksgiving. Ready? Most Christian men misunderstand this concept. The Bible never actually commands us to feel. That's air quotes. Feel thankful it's not actually what it says. It commands us to give thanks. You see feeling follows, practice.

Neuroscientists call [00:11:00] this top-down regulation. The idea that behavior can trigger emotion. When you speak gratitude out loud, even if you don't feel it, the prefrontal cortex lights up and starts calming the amygdala. That darn amygdala. We've talked about it a lot. I That's your fear center. That's that stress center.

That's that. Oh my God. I just gotta survive. 'cause everything's horrible. Yeah, that's that one. You're literally switching. Gratitude Circuits back on scripture says, give thanks in all circumstances. Not because every circumstance feels good, but because the practice of gratitude restores the heart. Seneca said, the cure lies in changing our attitude.

Gratitude begins as a discipline long before it becomes a feeling. So here's the go-to move. Every morning, this week, just speak one sentence [00:12:00] of gratitude out loud. It doesn't have to be anything profound. You don't have to like shake the foundations of what it just has to be true. Pick one thing, one sentence of gratitude.

It just has to be true, and that will start you on the healthy path. Biblical gratitude isn't a feeling you wait for, it's a practice that awakens the feeling you lost. So step one. Of regaining. Regaining your thankfulness is approaching gratitude as a discipline, not a feeling. Something you do because you should, because it's good for you, because it's necessary, not because you feel grateful.

Step two is about teaching your brain to seek gratitude. You see, your brain is, has this built in bias? Look for threats. It's called the negative attentional drift. It helps keep you alive, [00:13:00] but if you let it roam wild, it will only track what's wrong, which completely hijacks your gratitude and head you back into survival mode.

See, it's a good thing it keeps you alive, but it's that fear center, guys, we need to do something else with our brain because if we don't, that's just what it's gonna run on. The stoics understood this idea. Science, neuroscience is now confirming you can train your mind to see what is good. The STO has figured it out years and years ago, but neuroscience is now going, Hey, they were right.

Imagine that Philippians four, eight tells us to think about what is true, noble, right, and praiseworthy, even if you're not a Bible guy. That's reframing. That's what that is. Marcus Aurelius said. The happiness of your life depends on the quality of your thoughts. He wasn't [00:14:00] spouting poetry. That's cognitive rewiring.

So we're gonna use something our brains already naturally do to get us away from this negative attentional drift and get us back on track, we're gonna use something called the Bader Meyerhoff phenomenon. Something your brain is already familiar with. If you haven't heard it called that before, it's also referred to as the frequency illusion or frequency bias.

And it's that thing that happens when you have something you recently got bought. Like when you buy a new car as an easy example, you buy a new car and all of a sudden you realize that everybody, their dog drives the same car you just bought. Well, I mean, it's everywhere, but guess what? There aren't more than there were yesterday.

You are just more aware of it because of your present purchase. The effect is driven by two psychological processes, selective attention, where your brain subconsciously starts to notice the car more often [00:15:00] because it now holds personal significance and confirmation bias, which you interpret each sighting as proof that the car is suddenly more common.

That's what's happening. We have all done it. We've all experienced it. Well, the good news is. You can do it with gratitude as well. It's something I actually used to use with my kids before bed and I actually need to get back in the habit of doing. The tool I use is very simple. Three gratitudes. That was two, three gratitudes.

I shouldn't use fingers. Each day before my kids went to bed, I would ask them to name three things they were grateful for. So each day at the end of your day, name three tiny wins. Three things you're grateful for and appreciate. Not big ones, tiny ones, little wins. This person did something nice for me.

So and so said I looked good. My boss told me I did a good job. Three tiny wins to be grateful for [00:16:00] the RAS, which is the reticular activating system in your brain. Start searching for positive things to be grateful for instead of threats. Right. We're using the frequency bias to reprogram and get out of that I'm afraid mindset that's keeping us alive.

And what happens is the heart slowly wakes back up. Your brain becomes what you repeatedly focus on. So train it to see the good and gratitude returns. Now we got into step one of regaining, regaining your thankfulness. With approaching gratitude as discipline, not a feeling. And in step two, right, your brain is now actively looking for things to be grateful for.

We're training it to seek that. Well, step three is about turning the switch back on in your brain because stress will actually turn off your brain's ability to process [00:17:00] gratitude if you're not careful. So this is where we move from mindset to mechanism. Gratitude is not abstract. It's there's actually a biological base for it.

There's a circuit in your brain, in your prefrontal cortex to the anterior cate, to the limbic sys limbic system. I had to write that all down, guys, so I didn't screw that one up. The lights up. This lights up. Every time you experience gratitude, that's what happens. This is why I take notes about the neurological stuff I talk to talk about, so.

It's actually a circuit. This exists. This is in your biology. Stress can shut it off, but the good news is you can actually turn it back on. Psalms 51 says, restore to me the joy of thy of your salvation. Even David prayed for his heart to wake back up. The stoics believed that gratitude was about alignment with order meaning and purpose.

So here's a three minute gratitude activation that you [00:18:00] can use every single day this week. To start to reawaken that heart and to actually trigger that circuit back on that your stress has been shutting off. Slow your breathing for 30 seconds. I prefer Brock box breathing, but you can just slow down and take deep breaths as you want, if you want.

But slow down your breathing for 30 seconds. Visualize someone you deeply appreciate for one minute. See them in your mind and your heart. I mean, really focus on these people that just. Lights you up and then speak one sentence of gratitude out loud for one minute. This is not at the same time, this is one after the other.

So slow breathing, visualize, and then one sentence of gratitude. It can be something that like people call a mantra, right? Whereas you say the same thing over again. But it can be something as simple as, I'm so deeply grateful that my wife air quotes are my child or my [00:19:00] friend Bob. Whoever you need to do, right?

What? Whatever you're grateful for, whoever your person is. I'm so deeply grateful that my wife is in my life and they make my life so much more incredible. I'm so blessed. Verbally say it out outside, out loud to yourself over and over and over again for a minute. It can be something totally different, but you get the point, right?

Tracking with me. That's it. Three minutes. Three minutes and you are rewiring this circuit in your brain. The stress is often turning off in your head. Rewire that, strengthen that, build that neuro connection. In three minutes a day, you are rewiring your brain towards gratitude as opposed to fear.

Gratitude's not something you wait to feel is something you consciously switch on. One of the things I'm grateful for this season is our community over at Patreon. If you want more tools like this one, [00:20:00] deeper, raw, behind the scenes kind of conversations from all of our shows, private q and a, and our exclusive podcast Behind Closed Mics, the Messy Honest Truth of Grain.

As a man and creator join me over at Patreon, it directly supports our mission. It helps me reach and equip more men who are trying to live on purpose. So head over to patreon.com/the Fallible Man. We'd love to have you in the brotherhood, and it's a great community over there with lots of goodies, including our.

Exclusive podcast that nobody else gets. Now, step one of regaining your thankfulness is approaching gratitude as a discipline, not a feeling. Yes, I'm purposely repeating these over and over again. Step two is about teaching your brain to actually look for things to be grateful for. Step three is about switching the gratitude circuit back on so your brain can actually exper experience, gratitude.

And step four is about actively bringing it into your world. So let's bring it home. 'cause that's where [00:21:00] we really wanted to reside anyways, right? Gratitude isn't something that changes your internal world alone. It changes your relationships and your relationships are critical to your entire wellbeing.

So one of the big areas I focus on, because if your relationships are right, the rest of the world could be on fire and most time you're okay. Neuroscience tells us that expressing gratitude releases oxytocin, the bonding chemical. It lowers defensiveness. It increased trust. It strengthens connections.

One sentence of gratitude to your wife can shift the entire emotional climate of your home. One sentence of gratitude to your kids can shape their identity for the rest of their life. Proverbs tells us, life and death are in the power of the tongue. Your words create the emotional atmosphere your family lives in, and you really want that to be an atmosphere of gratitude.

Son Rufuss said, [00:22:00] virtue isn't real until it benefits others. Gratitude isn't complete until it's spoken. It has to be practiced with other people to take root and really living in your life. So here's your Thanksgiving blessing script. Tell your wife, I'm grateful for the strength you bring to our family.

Tell each kid, I'm proud of who you're becoming Every single day. Tell your friends, I'm so grateful for the encouragement and blessing you are to my life every day. And before you walk through the door of this Thanksgiving. Lord, help me bring presence, not pressure.

Gratitude spoken, becomes connection, felt. And it's how a man brings peace to his home. Now, guys, as we wind this down, understand you are not broken. You're not spiritually defective, you're [00:23:00] not emotionally weak. You've just been carrying too much for too long, with too few places to set it down. Your heart isn't numb, it's just exhausted.

And gratitude. Real gratitude, practiced. Gratitude has the power to bring your heart back online. This week. Don't just think thankful. Don't just post thankful. 'cause we all do that on the social, on the holidays, right? Speak it, practice it. Live it. Your family doesn't need a perfect man at the table this Thanksgiving.

They just need a present one. If this episode resonated with you, get on the mailing list over@purposedrivenmen.com. You'll get biweekly tools, frameworks, and content designed to help you become the man God created you to be on purpose with purpose, for purpose. I'll see you next time, and until then, live with purpose, lead with courage, and be better tomorrow because of what you do today and we'll see you on the next one.[00:24:00] 

The Driven 2 Thrive broadcast purpose, growth, and lasting impact for men, helping men go from living to thriving. Purpose-filled intentional lives. Affiliate disclaimer, my Pillow like any other Source Cycles, promos because of the extended lifecycle of a podcast. The immediate promotion that you heard mentioned in this episode may no longer be in effect when you hear it because you can be hearing this five years from when I recorded it.

However, as long as my Pillow is a sponsor of The Driven 2 Thrive broadcast, our show, our promo code Thrive is always good for up to 80% off your order and free shipping on orders over 75 no matter what you hear in this episode. As far as the current promo. Thrive is always good as long as my pillows sponsor the show for up to 80% off your order and free shipping five.